Emergence And Bootstrapping
Claim Type: mechanism_hypothesis
Scope: Language emergence and bootstrapping
Depends On: ARC-009, ARC-010
Status: candidate
Claim ID: MECH-010
Source: docs/processed/legacy_tree/architecture/language/emergence_and_bootstrapping.md
Elaborates Section 5 (Social Extension: Language) of
REE_CORE.md.
Emergence & Bootstrapping
REE predicts that language-like signalling emerges when:
- agents have private internal state (interoception/homeostasis),
- must model others under partial observability,
- benefit from coordination,
- plan over longer horizons,
- and operate under compute/attention limits.
Joint attention is the immediate precursor: once agents detect each other as OTHER_SELFLIKE, WORLD predictions improve by conditioning on what the other is attending to. That creates simulation overhead, which pressures the system to externalise predictive state.
Language therefore emerges as a compression and coordination layer, not a new reasoning engine.
Bootstrapping sequence (human-analogous but implementation-agnostic)
- Affective signalling (low-bandwidth, high-salience): distress, aversion, approach cues
- Attentional biases: agent/face-like feature attention; gaze-following analogues
- Proto-symbols: repeated signals tied to stable contexts (“danger”, “stop”, “help”)
- Symbolic compression: compositional messages that condition priors and plans
- Normative layer: shared expectations transmitted socially (still constrained by embodied harm)
Minimal requirement
REE does not require pre-defined grammar or symbols—only a channel for exporting internal summaries that can update others’ priors.
Minimal nudges for bootstrapping:
- external symbol production (cheap, repeatable, perceivable outputs),
- attention coupling to those symbols,
- commitment tagging for some patterns,
- fast correction tokens (“no”, “wait”, “stop”).
Dual-stream nudge (functional analog):
- a dorsal sequence→motor channel for fast sensorimotor mapping, paired with a ventral meaning channel for semantic grounding (distributed rather than a single tract; see
arcuate_fasciculus.md). —
Open Questions
None noted in preserved sources.
Related Claims (IDs)
- MECH-010
References / Source Fragments
docs/processed/legacy_tree/architecture/language/emergence_and_bootstrapping.md